I've just spent several hours working on charting the "Springtime" lace, and I see why I got hung up before! This is a pretty intricate pattern. For each shawl in the book (Stahman's Shawls & Scarves), Myrna has included a "building block," which is the basic unit for all the other charts. The "Elizabeth" and "Josephine" have the largest building blocks in the book: 32 rows X 18 stitches and 36 rows X 20 stitches, respectively. As best I can tell as this point (I haven't completely gotten the building block isolated to my satisfaction, although I think I just figured something out as I was writing this!), it's probably 24 rows X 38 stitches.
Working my swatch before, I decided that I didn't want to knit from the Kinzel charts directly (I'm not crazy about her symbols), and I wanted to have the freedom to arrange things in the same way Myrna has, and so I'm re-charting everything. It makes more sense to me as I read it, but it's slow going. To chart this pattern and have it make visual sense requires quite a few "no stitch" blocks, so it's not a straightforward process. Here's a little clip of my first try (the gray blocks indicate "no stitch" and the pink blocks are to remind me about a symbol that looks very like another one, but is worked differently).

As a side benefit, however, I 'm learning a lot about charting lace, and about the structure of lace; things I've wanted to know for a long time. I'm using Mac OS X, Microsoft Excel, and developing my own lace charting font (using Macromedia's Fontographer to modify a knitting symbol font I got years ago from XRX, Inc.) It's slow going at times (I've been working on charting lace off and on for about two years now), but I think I'm getting there. And this will be useful knowledge for the future, not just for this shawl. As I mentioned a few days back, I also want to learn to use Adobe Illustrator so that I can more easily make schematics of my shawl ideas. I think I'm thinking along the same lines as Sivia, who posted a comment on my previous entry, but without a schematic, I can't be sure.
I keep thinking that it might be wise to go ahead and knit one of the shawls in Myrna's book before I strike out completely on my own (I was one of her "proof-knitters" but I didn't actually complete a shawl). I'm pretty sure it would be useful to understand a bit more about how these shawls are structured. And I want to be knitting, not just charting and "figuring!" We'll see what I decide. It feels a bit like a side path, but it might bring me back around to the main path with a much clearer idea of how to proceed, especially if I continue working on the charting (and on learning Illustrator as well) as I go along.
I did know this wasn't an easy project when I embarked on it! If it had been, I would have finished it two years ago when I first had the idea. And I am enjoying the process, and feel like I'll eventually end up with a lovely shawl (or two), so all is well! At least I'm engaged again, and making progress.
Posted by Shelda at June 21, 2003 05:34 PMWow, nice going! Wish there were a good lace charting program for OS X. I see lots of programs for Windows but precious few for Macs and even less for OS X. There's Cochenille, but they don't seem to be too up on what's the latest in the operating systems.
Posted by: Lola Lee at June 28, 2003 09:19 AM